Login
Remember
Register
Questions
Unanswered
Tags
Ask a Question
Ask a Question
Which Should i use Unit process or System Process?
+2
votes
3.4k
views
openlca
life cycle inventory (lci)
unit process
system process (lci)
asked
May 4, 2019
in
openLCA
by
Aayush Thapa
(
620
points)
Please
log in
or
register
to add a comment.
Please
log in
or
register
to answer this question.
1
Answer
+3
votes
answered
May 4, 2019
by
artur.szilagyi
(
2.3k
points)
selected
May 5, 2019
by
Aayush Thapa
Best answer
One difference between the two is that a system process is aggregated, which means it contains a inventory of all elementary flows combined for the preceding life-cycle stages = life-cycle inventory (LCI). So there's no need for providers, it's all in there.
On the other hand unit processes contain product flows that can be and should be tracked back to other processes or providers.
Which means using system processes results in smaller product systems with less links and thus shorter computation time / less CPU / less RAM usage but you loose detail as you cannot track back where your impacts coming from.
Also, a database containing only system processes is usually 10-20x bigger in size than the same database with only unit processes.
commented
Mar 9, 2022
by
sourabhjain
(
670
points)
"Also, a database containing only system processes is usually 10-20x bigger in size than the same database with only unit processes."
That is surprising. Shouldn't unit process database be bigger than the database with system processes? Why is that an aggregated database requires more memory than unit process database?
PS: I edited the original question.
commented
Mar 10, 2022
by
artur.szilagyi
(
2.3k
points)
This topic reminds me to classic CPU vs. RAM tradeoff in image compression: you either work with less compression so you need less CPU but more RAM, or vice versa, you work with more compression that requires more CPU but results in smaller storage footprint.
commented
Mar 10, 2022
by
sourabhjain
(
670
points)
Okay. I see. Since all calculations have been done before hand, you need more storage in systems process but less computation. In Unit process, you do all calculations "on the fly", so you need more RAM, but less hard disk storage. Is it right?
commented
Oct 13, 2022
by
talha_ta27
(
160
points)
And what about the results?
Is there any difference in overall results? Providing the same values for all the parameters.
commented
Oct 13, 2022
by
artur.szilagyi
(
2.3k
points)
In theory, there shouldn't be any difference. In practice it depends on how the aggregated dataset was generated.
commented
Oct 13, 2022
by
artur.szilagyi
(
2.3k
points)
@sourabjain: you're correct
Please
log in
or
register
to add a comment.
ask.openLCA
is a question-and-answer (Q&A) website on
Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)
.
It is also the public support platform for
openLCA
,
openLCA Nexus
,
data.openLCA
and the
LCA Collaboration Server
.
Before asking questions please also consult our online manuals for
openLCA
and the
LCA Collaboration Server
.
Receive guaranteed and prioritised professional support via
GreenDelta's help desk
.
ask.openLCA is run by
GreenDelta
, the creators of openLCA.
Categories
All categories
openLCA
(2.7k)
Miscellaneous
(165)
LCA Collaboration Server
(68)
Related questions
How to combine Ecoinvent Unit (UP) and System (LCI) datasets without loosing processes?
I still don't understand the difference between unit and system process. Could anyone explain it to me again?
Inputs section: Unit process use elementary flows and System process use product flows?
Unit Process vs System Process
Different calculation results for same Product systems with process type as System process vs Unit process
Why can the system process be displayed in the process contribution of the report instead of the unit process?
'System process' vs. 'Unit process' under Provider
Difference between system process and unit process
'Unit process' versus 'system process'
Why are ecoinvent 3.7 datasets all "unit processes" but show LCI results? Shouldn't those be "system processes"?
Follow @openlca
...