0 votes
65 views

I do not understand why Brazilian soybean in Ecoinvent has such a low land occupation flow. For example:

 

Per kg soybean:

 

Moto Grosso: 1.51E-4 m2.a

 

Bahia: 2.32E-4 m2.a

 

Goiás: 1.71E-4 m2.a

 

Paraná: 1.17E-4 m2.a

 

And these do not match with the yields indicated in the description. For example, for the Moto Grosso region, the yield is of 3356 kg/ha. The land occupation flow of 1.51E-4 m2.a would mean that:

 

Yield: 3120kg/ha/year = 0.312kg/m2/year.

 

Land required per kg: 1kg / 0.312kg/m2 ≈ 3.205m2.a/kg, and not the indicated 1.51E-4 m2.a.

 

Even if the soybean grows during less than a year, the difference between 3.205m2.a/kg and and 1.51E-4 m2.a is too big to be just this.

 

Many thanks for your help,

 

Best,

 

This suggests that producing 1kg of soybeans would typically require approximately 3.205m²·a of land occupation.

ago in Miscellaneous by (870 points)

1 Answer

0 votes
ago by (10.6k points)

Seems you are using an older version of ecoinvent than 3.11. In 3.10.1 and earlier you will find 1.51E-4m2 and in 3.11 you will find 1.51m2. This error from ecoinvent, that got correct in 3.11, seems to affect a lot of land use data sets in Brazil. Page 176 of the ecoinvent 3.11 change report:

A specific issue was identified in relation to calculation of land occupation for Brazilian (BR) datasets since they were estimated in ha*year instead of m2 *year. Table 87 shows which datasets are updated and their new values.

https://19913970.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hubfs/19913970/Knowledge%20Base/Database/Releases/3.11/Change%20Report%20v3.11.pdf

ago by (870 points)
Amazing, thank you for such a quick response!
Best,
...